The Western District of Virginia Federal Court recently ruled that an employee cannot bring class-action employment and benefits claims against his employer when he previously agreed to arbitrate them. Reinforcing recent federal decisions favoring employment arbitration, the Court stayed the employee’s claims concerning his layoff pending arbitration. The decision is Green v. Zachry Industrial, Inc., Civil Action No. 7:11CV00405 (W.D. Va. Mar. 25, 2014).
The employee worked for Zachry Industrial, Inc., a construction and industrial maintenance firm. At the start of employment, Zachry required all employees to sign an arbitration agreement referenced in the application for employment. When the employee and others were laid off suddenly by Zachry, the employee filed suit in federal court claiming that he was not given termination and benefits rights provided under federal law. These rights include advance notice of layoff under the WARN Act and notice of the right to continue health care insurance under COBRA, which at the time included a significant government subsidy of premiums provided by the stimulus package (the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009). The employer filed a motion to dismiss or stay the lawsuit and require arbitration, and the employee filed a motion to amend his lawsuit to include other similarly-situated employees as plaintiffs.
To prevent arbitration, the plaintiff challenged the authenticity of his signature on the arbitration agreement. The Court rejected this argument, finding that the employee signed an application apart from the arbitration agreement that proved the plaintiff’s consent to arbitrate. The plaintiff then argued that the arbitration agreement violated the “concerted activity” protections of the National Labor Relations Act by preventing him from bringing a collective or class action. The Court did not agree based upon a recent Supreme Court decision that arbitration agreements can be enforced even though they waive class action rights, and based upon a recent federal court ruling that such waivers do not violate the NLRA. The employee then claimed that the arbitration agreement was unconscionable because it required him to pay attorneys’ fees that he could otherwise recover in court under the WARN Act, COBRA and ERISA. The Court rejected this argument, finding that, while the employee would have to pay attorneys’ fees during arbitration, the arbitrator could award recovery of these fees under the arbitration agreement.
Finally, the employee challenged whether the arbitration agreement would cover COBRA and ERISA claims, which relate to post-employment benefits rather than disputes concerning employment. The Court found that the agreement’s broad language covering “any and all claims . . . arising out of or relating to . . . the terms and conditions of employment, and/or to the cessation of employment” would cover such claims.
This decision shows the increasing federal court support for employment arbitration agreements. Nevertheless, given the many challenges that can be made to prevent arbitration, employers who choose arbitration must make sure to refer to arbitration in their employment applications, make available extensive arbitrator remedies, and provide for broad coverage of claims.
Fill out the form and we’ll respond as soon as possible.
Posted on Google
AnonymousTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I was facing a charge of Reckless Driving for speeding on I66 at midnight. This is considered a Class 1 Misdemeanor in the state of Virginia. Having something like Reckless Driving on your record is on par with having a DUI. This charge also carries a chance for jail time (up to a year). I was incredibly scared because I had never faced such a charge. And looking into Virginia Law, my speed exceeded 90mph, which is quite serious. I retained Dave Albo to help me with this case. Since my record was clean, Dave had advised I do the following before my trial. * Take a DMV Driver's Improvement Course * Take a Behavior Modification Course * Do 100 hours of community service * Print my DMV Record one week before the trial On the day of my trial, Dave got my Reckless Driving charge REDUCED to a regular Speeding charge. This was the absolute best case scenario for me. No criminal record. No jail time. No suspension of license. I did receive 6 demerit points and had to pay a fine of $250 (plus court fees). But that's a slap on the wrist, compared to what I could have been facing. Thank you Dave Albo for helping me through this ordeal!Posted on Google
TomDave albo it's a fantastic lawyer. He has helped me twice now with great results both times with minor traffic tickets. I would recommend him to anybody including my family. He has great ethics and honesty which is what I look for in a lawyer .Posted on Google
kendall carpenterDave was my attorney recently for a car accident where I needed someone to represent me in court. After exchanging all necessary information he reassured me when the court date came that there wouldn’t be anything to worry about. On the day of court a couple problems arose and Dave was able to rectify them quickly, told me everything I need to say if needed and when it was all over he got my violation reduced significantly. I hope to never go to court again but if I do I will being calling Dave again.Posted on Google
Amanda StallardRetaining the services of Mr. Albo for traffic court was probably the best decision I made. He is very responsive to emails, knowledgeable, and punctual. He provided excellent advice that eased the panic of having to go to the court house and stand before a judge. I am very happy with the outcome of my visit to traffic court and highly recommend Dave Albo.Posted on Google
Mark WestMr Albo was very professional and I was pleased with the outcome.Posted on Google
MDavid was incredible to work with from clear communication and next steps. To showing up to traffic court early to walk over all steps, making case in court as experienced/intelligent/well spoken lawyer. Lastly, he even followed after case in writing to confirm the outcome outlining everything that happened in lamen terms (in my case the best outcome we could ask for). I’m so appreciative to David.Posted on Google
mitquinn88Absolutely top notch representation. Can't thank Dave enough for his knowledge and expertise.Posted on Google
G RThanks to Dave Albo for a fantastic job representing me and ensuring the best possible outcome for my case. I highly recommend him - you will be in good hands for sure. From start to finish he provided expert counsel and kept me well informed. He simply could not have done a better job.Posted on Google
Hope CarriganI am THRILLED with the outcome of my case, all thanks to Attorney Albo's superb expertise, excellent advice & sharp negotiating skills! I am extremely relieved and grateful; I highly recommend retaining his services. Well beyond worth it!!Posted on Google
Doug DamronDave did a great job representing me for my traffic court infraction! I wanted the best and his name came up as I searched for an attorney. Highly recommend him on all levels including a successful outcome to my case.
